Emotionally lucid acting (so real, it doesn't seem to be acting at all) - TheaterScene.net
James Foster Jr. (seeming like he just got off shift from doing this job and came to the theater) drives the bus that takes inmates from Rikers Island to dig the graves on Hart Island - TheaterMania
Foster can do more with a subtle shift in his expression than anyone I’ve seen in years - DC Theatre Scene
Foster brought verisimilitude to Hoke Coleburn - DC Metro Theatre Arts
James Foster Jr. is quite frightening as the ruthless Harry Roat Jr. – The Review
James Foster Jr.'s silver-haired, deep-voiced Preacher is the evening’s anchor - Washington City Paper
Foster skillfully assays a powerful older man painfully allowing his true emotions to rise to the surface and be revealed - Washington Blade
Foster, especially, provides a formidable stage presence as Pizarro - The Examiner
James Foster Jr. is a wonderfully slimy Professor Claude Knight, a noble Othello, a fiery Tybalt, but tops it all off as Juliet’s Nurse - The Montgomery County Sentinel
James Foster Jr. as the homicidal son, Ronnie, is powerful – The Washington Post
James Foster Jr., as Chris, handles a complex role with ease - The Washington Post
James Foster Jr. is exceptional...strangely gentle - a grenade with the pin already pulled - The Star-Ledger
James Foster Jr. (D.J Jackson) gives a brilliant performance - The Sun